Subscribe
Notify of
guest

23 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris1
Chris1
14 years ago

I thought Camelot was epic. Just the whole hopelessness of the situation with ships getting destroyed everywhere. The destruction of the Korolev was shocking and sad :(.

Teal’C swoopping down into battle with the Lucian alliance though seemed like a direct ripoff of the battle sequence in DS9 where the Klingon’s showed up at the last minute in the battle to retake Deep Space Nine.

lukicc
lukicc
14 years ago

Well Stargate does find inspiration in the world of sci-fi. Space battles are at its best when odds are at their worst :)

BTW, the “they’d better mention Be All My Sins Remember’d” reader should be pleased it made it into the first position! Yay

The Tenth Doctor
The Tenth Doctor
14 years ago

Pretty much the full list I had in my head. Good stuff.

HollyWood
HollyWood
14 years ago

I have to say that I don’t have any arguments on this weeks Friday five, Be All My Sins Remember’d do have a lot of cool stuff especially with the fact that they are teaming up with the Wraith and the Travellers(I believe that that’s what you call them in general, but I’m not quite sure). That episode is by far one of my favourite in the Atlantis show.

Dactyls
Dactyls
14 years ago

I think the swooping in to save the day was done long before DS9…Han Solo anyone? :P

JoshuaJSlone
14 years ago

It would be entertaining to see a pre-Lost City version of this list.

We have a number of… shuttles.

WillKatt
WillKatt
14 years ago

Those are all cool battles but one I had in my head did not make it here. May be it’s not as cool as the listed ones, but for some reason the first thing I remembered on the subject was the “Lost Tribe”, when Drs Jackson & McKay turned on the Atero device under pressure from lost Asgards and the crew of Dedalus is overtaken with Tood believing them responsible for this terrible effect ripping our the Hive ships in hyperspace. Oh, I see, it is not so much a battle but one of the coolest scenes in space with… Read more »

Sylvia
Sylvia
14 years ago

Agree with everything on your list!

Crispyduck
Crispyduck
14 years ago

I just think its a shame the The Siege wasn’t in space.

Crispyduck
Crispyduck
14 years ago

Well part 3 was I suppose.

lordofseas
lordofseas
14 years ago

I liked the Battle of the Void. :/ We got to see Atlantis have an Aurora in action. In this case, the Orion.

s09119
s09119
14 years ago

I disagree with this list… “Enemy at the Gate” had an awful battle, with terrible logic and even-worse special effects. IMO, it should read:

5. “The Siege, Part 3”
4. “No Man’s Land”
3. “Be All My Sins Remember’d”
2. “Camelot”
1. “Lost City, Part 2”

Balesirion
Balesirion
14 years ago

What the heck? No mention of “Reckoning, Part 2”? That one was certainly much better than “Enemy at the Gate” or “The Hive”.

superman71099
superman71099
14 years ago

what about “Unending”? Orilla destroyed and the Odyssey armed to the teeth taking out Ori motherships. Plus, there was the five minutes of “Air” that was up on YouTube for a bit the other day. All I can say is wow. The George Hammond vs Ha’tak mothership while 302s fight death gliders, amazing.

markuskorpela
markuskorpela
14 years ago

Good list. Be All My Sins Remembere’d is good, no doubt, but only second best (in my opinion). Best would be No Man’s Land. The Battle of Void (I guess they call it that) is just intense. It’s not long, but the energy in it is just amazing.

s09119
s09119
14 years ago

Okay, I lied. I completely forgot about “Reckoning, Part 2,” and now I’m very annoyed that it isn’t on the list. That definitely deserves top 5, so boot “Be All My Sins Remember’d” down a little more…

Ziel
Ziel
14 years ago

Well personnally my top 5 are: 1) Lost City (Battle over Earth & Antartica) I think that this battle is pure gold. 2) No Man’s Land (Battle Of The Void – 2 Hives versus the Daedalus & the Orion) Brillant battle, both sides had 2 ships & by the end of the weapons blazing both had lost 1. So it was much more realistic than BAMSR. 3) Ark Of Truth (The Odyssey fending off multiple Ori Ships in the Ori Galaxy) I just really liked how this battle was done. 4) Enemy At The Gate (Atlantis versus the Superhive) No… Read more »

theStormWeaver
theStormWeaver
14 years ago

The only reason so many of the allied ships survived in BAMSR is because we outnumbered the Asuran ships and FRAN removed all of their crews minutes after the battle started. If it had gone on for much longer we would have experienced huge losses, I’m sure.

Ziel
Ziel
14 years ago

I’m pretty sure that we were actually, just about, out numbered for that battle. I agree about the FRAN thing though.
But still I did say ”personally”. LOL.

Emily
Emily
14 years ago

I think the Chair will be in it, if you consider atlantis, that will be there too.

Emily
Emily
14 years ago

I know number 1, the stargate baby!

mvrck
mvrck
14 years ago

I’m honestly amazed neither No Man’s Land or Daedalus Variations got a nod. NML was simply an amazing battle with a thought out battle plan, instead of your typical “show up and shoot at them.” It might be the ONLY time SG-1 or SGA has actually tried to apply real tactics to a space battle. Variations had simply the best small ship fight scene I’ve seen. I really felt it blew away anything I’ve seen on any other shows for fighter battles, BSG included. The long trailing shot of the F-302 and the alien ship flying along the Daedalus’s hull… Read more »

Emily
Emily
14 years ago

What happened to the Friday 5!! i miss it I look forward to it every saturday