25 Responses

  1. Mentat
    Mentat
    (141 comments)
    December 20, 2010 at 9:09 pm |

    Funny how the podcast starts with the great music that made Stargate so enjoyable. Soundtrack — Reason 7 right there for you.

  2. sgfan
    (74 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 11:16 am |

    Good podcast Darren, David, and Diana. I agree with many comments made. I think this kind of show is very niche and it did have some cards stacked against it. But I still can’t help but feel that shows like this can be a success if they’re done the right way. It just has to be really good. As was mentioned the new Star Trek reboot did very well. I’m just thinking this show wasn’t the right one for the current market. I’m not knocking the show itself but it was in a tough position given the tone of the show, it’s time slot, the slow start to season 1, lack of good promotion, the list goes on.

    I hope the producers of the show can find a way to continue on with the SG1 and SGA movies despite this setback. Although it’s doubtful those will ever be made. Perhaps they can do something creative and do a mini-series wrap of SGU straight to DVD/Blu-ray. I don’t know how many folks feel this way but I’d be happy to shell out a few bucks to see the show come to a proper conclusion.

  3. wganubis
    wganubis
    (118 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 1:51 pm |

    The Pop up podcase and RSS feed dont seem to want to play through IE.

  4. wganubis
    wganubis
    (118 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 1:52 pm |

    Never mind, seems that it took longer than ussual to load.

  5. Arrakis2013
    Arrakis2013
    (5 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 2:08 pm |

    Move Stargate back home to Showtime!

  6. ThomasG
    ThomasG
    (23 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 2:12 pm |

    I think the franchise is dead, no more stargate SG:1, SG:A or SG:U. In any form.

  7. SG-17
    SG-17
    (6 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 2:51 pm |

    Honestly I think that the only place that Stargate can go from this point forward, especially after seeing how a purely arc driven show was received, is to go with full public disclosure of the Stargate program to the people of Earth. Not only would this allow for the continuation of all three ongoing arcs (Lucian Alliance War, Wraith War, and Destiny’s Mission) but it would allow for more of the “close to home” type episodes like SG-1 was filled with.

    I think that the distance, both literal and figurative, that Universe had with our Earth and our galaxy was a major “why should I care” factor in the show. The mission being introduced so late was also a hurting factor.

    I fully believe that a series based around the actions that Homeworld Command takes during and following the Lucian Alliance attack on Earth (which should be the catalyst for full disclosure) in regards to both ongoing wars, public reaction to the Program, and whatever Destiny finds would be much more successful than either Universe or Atlantis ever was. This would entail a more episodic layout with a slightly thicker overall arc than what SG-1 and Atlantis had, yet nowhere near the arc driven nature of Universe.

  8. Saquist
    Saquist
    (42 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 5:45 pm |

    SGU’s failure wasn’t about the market. It was slow and boring, dark and depressing. Why are the masses over analyzing the debacle. The very concept and characters empathetic relation with the audience. We had a lot of talk about more realistic characters but is pettiness what we want see out of everyone?

  9. thefatcontroller
    thefatcontroller
    (1 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 10:29 pm |

    SG-17 – I completely agree. The Stargate becoming public knowledge would have been a defining moment of the series, opening up huge possibilities. To me this would have been a far more natural progression of the Stargate story than what Stargate Universe was.

  10. Sylvia
    Sylvia
    (594 comments)
    December 21, 2010 at 11:29 pm |

    From what I have read, SGU had a significantly higher skweing male to female viewer ratio than the previous incarnations. You need to figure out why the women didn’t show up for this one.

    One reason might be shallow, but SGU didn’t have quite the same eye candy for the lady viewers like SG1 and SGA did. Could be a partial reason for the 80/20 split in the M/F demographics.

    I think female viewers really like “bromances” in their shows too.

  11. sg1sga
    sg1sga
    (13 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 12:01 am |

    SGU didn’t have more realistic characters, they just had different characters. Believe it or not, military men and women do have personality–and SG1 and SGA choose to depict more warming characters. SGU chose to be like BSG instead of being like Stargate. There is a way to progress the franchise and draw in new fans without saying FU to the fans that made the franchise.

  12. meezergater
    meezergater
    (3 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 7:37 am |

    i followed SGU the last year on sci fi channel europe and like was said here it found it pretty dissapointing.
    Very slow story, not much action, i really miss a crew that catches on.
    the writers would do good to go back to form a hot group of actors that do at appeal to the public and with a much faster story with at least more humor in it. The SGU story was much to dark with a storyline that didn’t go anywhere and wasn’t very atractive to follow.
    But most important i think this set of actors just didn’t do it. (and like Flanigan would say, “not because we’re….old….”

  13. Duneknight
    Duneknight
    (153 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 7:54 am |

    what would be the point of having stargate public knowledge? it changes nothing to the stories. absolutly nothing. there are already corporations, international gov, nerdy kids involved in the sg program to a degree. Who else do you want? what do you want out of such a huge change to the premise?

  14. US06154
    US06154
    (73 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 10:25 am |

    Just throwing an idea out there. Since the Entire Stargate Franchise was cancelled on SGU’s watch, perhaps the SGU fans failed the entire franchise. If they (SGU Fans) decided to DVR and Download to watch later, without watching it live, Because something else was on, can they be considered true SGU Fans? just sayin’..

  15. Gaeth
    Gaeth
    (103 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 10:30 am |

    @sg1sga: It did not & you know it. BSG was garbage, pure garbage. SGU was great, it had adventure, exploration *and* character drama You’re just recycling the same talking points. Enjoy your re-runs.

  16. Piernik
    Piernik
    (45 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 10:51 am |

    They schould release two new shows:

    Stargate Wrestling – with fighters from all galaxies . In episode one Jaffa would be fighting with a Wraith warrior. We would see how they train, some interviews etc. Iw would be very exciting! The looser will lose everything (Jaffa will be executed with his all family and Wraith team will loose one hive ship).

    Dancing with a Goa’uld
    A system lord is looking for a new host in a galaxy best dancing tvshow. The host will be changed in each season and the loosers will work as a slaves in a mining :)

  17. US06154
    US06154
    (73 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 12:24 pm |

    @Piernik: you Forgot,
    Wraith Chef – A show where the Wraith show you different ways of how suck the life out your victims.

    Survivor Pegasus – Where a bunch of misfits are stranded in an unknown galaxy, Far, Far away.. Wait, That sounds a whole lot like SGU.. So scrap that idea.

  18. Jago77
    Jago77
    (75 comments)
    December 22, 2010 at 1:36 pm |

    Lol Piernik
    Hilarious stuff =)

  19. rsharpe
    rsharpe
    (60 comments)
    December 23, 2010 at 4:11 am |

    I’m just coming up blank as to suggestions on what would have saved the show.

  20. DarkElfa
    DarkElfa
    (69 comments)
    December 23, 2010 at 5:07 pm |

    I’m curious what this will mean for the future of Gateworld as it’s bread and butter was an audience coming here for info and to discuss new episodes.

  21. wingsabre
    wingsabre
    (33 comments)
    December 26, 2010 at 4:28 am |

    I don’t understand how they couldn’t alternate series after Smackdown, similar to how Showtime staggers their series, and how AMC staggers Breaking Bad, followed by Mad Men, then followed by Walking Dead. They don’t air it all in one night. It would have made sense to have Caprica follow Smackdown, followed by SGU, and then Sanctuary, and then return with the same pattern after Sanctuary finishes it’s mid-season break.

  22. upperdeckhr
    upperdeckhr
    (3 comments)
    December 27, 2010 at 10:01 am |

    TV executives can cancel every show on air right now but they will not tell me how to use my DVR.

  23. SpaceGypsies » Blog Archive » State of the Franchise
    (366 comments)
    December 30, 2010 at 8:42 pm |

    […] “Six Reasons SGU Was Cancelled”, I found great hope in it, and I highly recommend that everyone listen to it. Remember how I mentioned that in discussing SGU with some GateWorld team members at a convention, […]

  24. Gaeth
    Gaeth
    (103 comments)
    January 2, 2011 at 9:05 pm |

    Legend of the Seeker was *not* arc based in any way. It was the opposite of an arc driven show. You could watch the first 2 episodes of the season & the last episode & you would have missed nothing. It didn’t reward loyalty, I still watched it though. Oh, BSG & Caprica are still awful.

  25. MarkA
    MarkA
    (2 comments)
    January 4, 2011 at 4:57 am |

    I hope the failure of SG-U doesn’t end the Stargate franchise as a whole. There were some very good actors in SG-U, but the producers basically got the formula wrong. They tried to incorporate the dreariest parts of BSG and in the process, turned off a lot of Stargate supporters. They idea might of SG-U might have been good, but it didn’t work so lets move on. Just because us Stargate fans generally were less impressed with SG-U, doesn’t mean we’ve stopped liking Stargate! So give us the SG-A movie, then perhaps another SG-1 movie and in meantime come up with a concept for a new Stargate series. And so you producers, just because SG-U was less than well received, don’t just take your bat and ball and run away!

Leave a Reply