Subscribe
Notify of
guest

29 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sylvia
Sylvia
12 years ago

I’m glad David loves McKay and wants to play him again. (just wish it would have been in the movie…)
Receiving decidedly mixed feelings from those who are tweeting him though. If you do a search of twitter, many are feeling a bit betrayed, many are quite happy about the crossover.

psw
psw
12 years ago

I fear the worst. They already completely changed the O’Neill character in SGU. I didn’t recognized him anymore! Carter didn’t even try to rescue those pilots and Daniel Jackson was misused as an agent with a camera. I think McKay and Woolsey will be the next characters from the two older Stargate series, which will be mistreated in SGU. I bet we will see again a complete personality change of those characters.

sgfan
12 years ago

@psw. I respectfully disagree about O’Neill. I think he’s toned down, but he’s also playing the role of commander and if you remember he was hard ass on occasion when he needed to be. I do think young is a screw up and O’neill needs to kick his ass. As for Carter and Jackson I agree their roles have been unsubstantial. Too bad it sounds like McKay will be just another brief cameo and non-integral to the plot. Too bad, as I would like to see McKay and Woolsey used in a way that’s more important to the story. IMO,… Read more »

ashizuri
ashizuri
12 years ago

I’m not an SGA fan, but I’m fairly excited to see Mckay again. I think they’ve done a great job with Jack, and I think even Daniel and Sam have made believable cameos, so I’m interested to see a slightly darker version of McKay.

psw
psw
12 years ago

@ sgfan O’Neill is my favourite SG1 character and they changed him so much in SGU, that I didn’t like him anymore. When they use SG1 or SGA characters in SGU, they should still have the same personality than in the previous series. They shouldn’t tone them down; the personality traits and eccentricities shouldn’t be reigned in. Those aspects make them the characters we know. They shouldn’t bother to include SG1 and SGA characters, if they changed them so much that you can’t recognized them anymore. If they need characters with a different personality, they should just introduce new characters… Read more »

krazzed
krazzed
12 years ago

Wow, Seriously what is the point of having Mckay if you take away and tone down his personality. I would prefer for them not to bother if they arent going to ring true to the actual characters. Doesn’t everyone realise that the only reason they are including these cameos is to keep veteran viewers tuning in so the ratings look good. While SGU does have some qualities most of the time they might as well be in a huge submarine in the bottom of the ocean for all the Sci-fi there is. But hey what do i know, im just… Read more »

xxxevilgrinxxx
xxxevilgrinxxx
12 years ago

I’m really looking forward to seeing this, especially if it’s a toned down McKay, more in keeping with the feel of SGU. (And I liked the treatment of O’Neill’s character in SGU. I think it worked and I have faith that McKay will work as well.)

Change is good :)

Stargaters
Stargaters
12 years ago

Lol @ the people saying that SGU has changed O’Neill and will change McKay. Remember the line “We’ll beam you up to our spaceship”? That line from the SGU pilot was exactly the kind of think the SG-1 O’Neill would say, and is just one example from SGU. Some people must think O’Neill was a complete joker and never serious in SG-1.

I’m looking forward to seeing McKay SGU.

krazzed
krazzed
12 years ago

@evilgrin “change is good” I remember alot of governments saying that…now look what happened!

davey1983
davey1983
12 years ago

,
I get were you are coming from, but I also must disagree. SGU O’neil is very similar to the Movie or early SG-1 O’neil. Also, O’neil cracked an inappropriate joke at an inappropriate time during his visit on the Destiny– more like the O’neil of later seasons.

As for McKay– I hope his appearance is more substantial than what is being implied here. While I enjoyed seeing Jackson and Carter on SGU, there were ultimately unsatisfying due to how short and fleeting they were.

Supertrinko
Supertrinko
12 years ago

I think it’s important to see these characters change. That’s what happens when people get older and take on new responsibilities. O’neill is heading defenses and operations for earth, forgive him if he’s not his usual self, especially in the serious situations that we’ve seen him in. Carter had no choice but to leave those pilots, she’s commanding a ship, it was either losing everyone, or just the pilots.

It’s easy to be yourself when someone else is in charge, when you don’t have those responsibilites. But O’Neill and Carter are in those leadership positions now.

Duneknight
Duneknight
12 years ago

i cant wait for this one. yeah McKay fits well in SGU if you ask me, I just wish he can boss someone around in that show, and show them how its done. Dr. Rush, you mightve blown up two planets but Dr. Mckay blew up a whole star system!

mistergroenevingers
mistergroenevingers
12 years ago

It’ll be nice to see mcKay in action again.
Technical question: Can it still be called a crossover if one of the two series has been dead for 2 years and there will therefore be no appearing of Destiny or SGU cast in SG Atlantis?

Funk01
Funk01
12 years ago

yep, ive seen mixed tweets some will only tune in for this one ep. so it better live up to expectations or there will be many unhappy Mckay fans. A few mins on screen or a toned down Mckay who does not mention atlantis and its people will not go down well with this fan. though new fans may like him as he will fit in with the show they like. I would rather have seen Mckay in his element on sga in the promised movie!

krazzed
krazzed
12 years ago

@ supertrinko Mmmm so im guessing while O’neil was saving the planet god knows how many times he didnt have any responsibility??? Are you telling me Barrack Obama’s personality has changed so much since he became president? NO! Its a weak argument! If Carter had been like she was in SGU in SG1 then im sure the team would of died lots of times. The only reason and i mean the ONLY reason they have these people making appearances is to capture people who dont really like SGU but LOVE SGA or SG1 to boost the ratings. Hence why its… Read more »

kellx
kellx
12 years ago

can’t wait to see Mckay again! they have done really well with carter and oneill in SGU but daniel as a spy was a little too far. Sam and jack have clearly been placed in major leadership positions and their characters reflect that change. Besides sam’s hair being kinda brown, she seemed like she just finished up where EAG left off. Same with Jack, he is in charge of home world security, he has to be serious but you still see his personality come out. It makes for a much more believable character arc. Daniel was completely miss used. I… Read more »

zainea13
zainea13
12 years ago

I agree Teal’c would have been a much better character (or Ronon) for the spy part. Jackson in the mind of Rush was good though. Very Jackson-y. What his role is at the SGC I have no idea. Head of the department of research into archaeology? That’s all I can think of.

sgfan
12 years ago

I think people forget characters change over time. Carter, Jackson, O’Neill, McKay, etc. They have all changed from the start of the series to the end. Not only that but the tone of the characters do change from episode to episode. Certainly there are lighter/funnier/goofy episodes and there are episodes that heavier/serious/dramatic. The characters tone is changed to accommodate what is called for in the story. Still, there is a character voice or spirit of the character that has to remain true. It is important to respect the spirit of the character. As long as the writers can do that… Read more »

Kosh
Kosh
12 years ago

All real-world casting issues aside, from a purely Stargate perspective, McKay should have been one of the very first to be sent to Destiny to help figure out it’s systems etc.! I’m really glad he’s finally going to make it there, even if it’s just a short visit. Hopefully he’ll have a breakthrough of some kind and piss off Rush who is already prone to jealousy. But man, I’d give it all up to get an Atlantis movie or two!!! My first thoughts reading this article were wondering if they were even going to mention anything like what the heck… Read more »

psw
psw
12 years ago

@ Kosh

We don’t know if McKay will be stoned to the Destiny. Maybe he will stay all the time in the Milky Way Galaxy with his mind. Should they send him to the Destiny, everyone would expect that he would solve a lot of technical problems. I don’t think that TPTB really want that. Otherwise he or Carter would have been on the Destiny at the beginning of season 1. I think they don’t want to make it “easy” for the Destiny crew. So I really wouldn’t be surprised, if we won’t see McKay on the Destiny.

puddlejumper_1
puddlejumper_1
12 years ago

I hope they get Stargate Extinction out in 2011 before cast members of sga go to sgu. Because if characters from sgu ask about atlantis it will definetely spoil the movie. Also to those talking how Carter’s character changed by leaving the 302 pilots behind, they put her in a real big bind. One of Hammonds biggest mandates is to never leave a person behind, and Carter did just that. Carter could have told the 302 pilots to use their hyperdrives and rendevous somewhere, but instead she just left them. And if im not correct about the hyperdrives im sorry,… Read more »

Scott Watson
12 years ago

Someone created a thread on the forum based on these comments: http://forum.gateworld.net/threads/76799-Hewlett-s-Crossover-discussion-…-and-comments

Darren
Admin
12 years ago

: In defense of Sam, she had seconds to act to save her ship and everyone on board. The ethic of not leaving our people behind does not make difficult command decisions go away. As Jack made clear to Everett later in the episode, that was a ridiculously hard thing for a CO to do.

I don’t think we have any evidence that F-302s have hyperdrives. The original X-302 prototype did (“Redemption”), but they never got it to work right.

trackback

[…] egy hosszabb interjút David Hewlettel a nemrég megrendezett GateConon. Ennek egy kis részletét tették közzé tegnap, amiben Hewlett a crossoverről […]

grif
grif
12 years ago

if it aint broke done fix it. end this show then end atlantis before mgm goes bye bye

erinsgobragh
12 years ago

That would be so awesome! I miss McKay!

domdom
domdom
12 years ago

IMO this will change nothing for me.The only idea that hits my mind is TPTB want to appeal “old” audience to improve sgu’s one and another bone. I’ve the worst worries about MacKay in sgu.I love him in SGA and especially his banters with Sheppard.I’ve worries about Mackay in sgu that would only be the shadow of himself and he would loose everything that made his success and identity in sgu. It’s really not a crossover cos SG1 and SGA are cancelled by the ones that needed help from former characters.In addition I noticed Mackay and Woolsey are the only… Read more »

brian577
brian577
12 years ago

I’m sorry, but I don’t think even Rodney McKay can get me to watch SGU again

Ganthet Jr.
Ganthet Jr.
12 years ago

For the love of…

Whoever said that SGU has changed O’Neill is delusional. He’s had SO many more serious, dark, and grim moments on SG1 with MUCH more intensity. I’ve actually appreciated his SGU appearances because he’s more like he was pre-season 9 of SG1. I’m perfectly willing to accept that many people hate this show. I understand and respect that. But don’t hate simply out of principle.