Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sylvia
Sylvia
10 years ago

2nd favorite episode of the series (after Vegas). That Beer on the pier scene is such classic McKay and Sheppard friendship, I love it. “You’re a good friend Arthur.”

ictus75
ictus75
10 years ago

One of the best episodes of the whole Stargate franchise…

Visam
Visam
10 years ago

Agreed it’d be hard to find one that was better. I think most of the best episodes had Rodney and his sister in them.

It’s amazing how Rodney transformed from SG-1 to this point in Atlantis where you actually care enough to care about his affliction.

scootermom
scootermom
10 years ago

Absolutly one of the best, if not the best. A lot of heart in this episode. Very touching, especially in the kind and gentle manner the others treated Rodney.

jacquicondon
jacquicondon
10 years ago

A great episode, definitely ‘up there’ as one of the best. Some lovely touching moments. It really shows how the characters have bonded as a family. The pier scene is the best!

Steve B
Steve B
10 years ago

Well, on an emotional side. It was a great episode. Overall, I didn’t care much to see it only because it only reminds me of what happens in real life with Alzheimers. I think its one of the worst ways to go. I just don’t like being reminded of it. There was great acting in this episode. David did an excellent job.