Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sylvia
Sylvia
9 years ago

2nd favorite episode of the series (after Vegas). That Beer on the pier scene is such classic McKay and Sheppard friendship, I love it. “You’re a good friend Arthur.”

ictus75
ictus75
9 years ago

One of the best episodes of the whole Stargate franchise…

Visam
Visam
9 years ago

Agreed it’d be hard to find one that was better. I think most of the best episodes had Rodney and his sister in them.

It’s amazing how Rodney transformed from SG-1 to this point in Atlantis where you actually care enough to care about his affliction.

scootermom
scootermom
9 years ago

Absolutly one of the best, if not the best. A lot of heart in this episode. Very touching, especially in the kind and gentle manner the others treated Rodney.

jacquicondon
jacquicondon
9 years ago

A great episode, definitely ‘up there’ as one of the best. Some lovely touching moments. It really shows how the characters have bonded as a family. The pier scene is the best!

Steve B
Steve B
8 years ago

Well, on an emotional side. It was a great episode. Overall, I didn’t care much to see it only because it only reminds me of what happens in real life with Alzheimers. I think its one of the worst ways to go. I just don’t like being reminded of it. There was great acting in this episode. David did an excellent job.