Is Stargate Origins Canon? Producers Say ‘Yes’

The Stargate franchise is going back to the beginning this week with the premiere of Stargate Origins, a short-form digital Web series that debuts Thursday exclusively at Stargate Command.

In a series of ten 10-minute episodes, Origins will tell the story of a young Catherine Langford — the matriarch of the Stargate program who recruited Daniel Jackson in the 1994 movie — who goes to great lengths to rescue her father from the Nazis in 1939.

But is Stargate Origins an “official” part of the venerable franchise’s canon? Producers of the digital series say yes.

“The canon questions are completely valid, and ones we paid close attention to,” a source close to the production told GateWorld. “Not only is Stargate Origins part of the existing canon, but that existing canon actually forms the very basis for this new exploration of Catherine Langford’s story.”

Discussion among fans who have read the project’s synopsis and watched the trailer often focus in on those bits of continuity that have been established with respect to the 1930s and 1940s. The Stargate was uncovered in Giza, Egypt in 1928, and shipped across the Atlantic ocean on board the Achilles sometime near the outbreak of World War II in 1939 (Stargate: Continuum). By 1945 the U.S. military was supporting Dr. Langford’s work, and Ernest Littlefield was lost through the gate when workers randomly dialed a valid address (“The Torment of Tantalus”).

While that leaves some important gaps that Origins can fill in, one especially large continuity matter remains: Will Catherine go through the Stargate in 1939? And if she does, will she remember it after the fact?

By all appearances Catherine doesn’t know how to dial the Stargate successfully in the feature film, and doesn’t make her first pass through the event horizon (nervously!) until 1997’s “The Torment of Tantalus.”

What, then, could have happened in 1939? Our source tells GateWorld that the scattered bits that we already know about this era in Stargate history in fact informed the story of Origins in a big way.

“During the early stages of this show’s creation, everyone involved took great inspiration from a number of references that the existing canon had made to the pre- and post-war era. So much so, that these references formed the basis for a large part of the Stargate Origins narrative.”

That would include the Germans, who acquired the D.H.D. from a Giza dig all the way back in 1906 (“The Tomb”). (It would be confiscated by the Russian government after the war, according to “Watergate.”) Since the Nazis play a big role as the antagonists in Origins, it stands to reason that they already know something about the Stargate when Dr. Wilhelm Brücke encounters the Langfords.

But let’s set Stargate Origins aside for a moment and ask a broader question.

WHAT COUNTS AS ‘CANON’?

The question of what material counts as canonical differs from one franchise to the next — especially in the era of new media, where stories are told far beyond the confines of a television screen. Gene Roddenberry reputedly restricted Star Trek canon only to what happens on screen in a TV show or film; J. Michael Straczynski opened up Babylon 5 canon a bit wider to also include a select number of tie-in novels (though not all of them).

With Stargate the question of canonicity is a bit more tricky. The TV series departed from the film’s source material in some significant ways (was Ra a Roswell grey-type alien? or a snake-like parasite? Which galaxy is Abydos in, again?). This already requires a bit of speculation and fuzzy logic to place the movie and the TV shows in the same universe.

There’s also the fact that neither the Devlin-Emmerich team nor the Wright-Glassner-Cooper team have ongoing involvement with the franchise today, including Stargate Origins. MGM (the studio that owns the rights to Stargate) does put tie-in material through a rigorous vetting process — but this is more for legalities and major flaws than for the more particular bits of story continuity. (Going forward the studio could certainly benefit from something akin to Lucasfilm’s Story Group. That MGM could be thinking along these lines might be signaled by the hiring of Kieran Dickson last year as Editorial Director.)

Take for example the events that reputedly take place after the series finale of Stargate Atlantis. Does the city ever return to the Pegasus Galaxy? How, and under what conditions? Three different versions of that story actually exist: Fandemonium’s official licensed Stargate Atlantis: Legacy novel series, American Mythology’s equally licensed “Back to Pegasus” comic series, and the complete screenplay for the unproduced film Stargate: Extinction.

Which of the three versions of these events is canon? With contradicting media tie-ins and a movie script that never made it to screen, the answer is none of them. In theory, another writer could come along and create a new, live-action Atlantis project with MGM, filling in the story in ways that disregard all previous efforts.

What’s clear is that, at this stage, licensed tie-ins should not be considered canon — if for no other reason than the fact that they can contradict one another, as there is no central clearing house to ensure that they do not. This would apply also to Alderac’s Stargate role-playing game (which evidently makes internal claims to being canon), and the animated series Stargate Infinity.

(Historical footnote: The big-budget MMO video game Stargate Worlds was intended to be canon, with Brad Wright and Robert C. Cooper hired as story consultants. The game never made it to market, and so future writers will of course be free to ignore its surviving materials.)

FILLING IN HISTORY

As for Stargate Origins, moving backward rather than forward on the Stargate timeline posed to the writers a different set of continuity challenges. That includes a lead protagonist who would convince her colleagues — and viewers! — in the 1990s that she had never been through the Stargate.

Some production decisions are simply artistic, or dictated by budgetary needs. The design of the Stargate and its chevrons in Origins, for example, is closer to the movie than the television series. The webisodes also echo 1994’s Stargate in a number of visuals, sound effects, and musical cues.

“We had a lot of fun doing a deep dive into the original movie, the seasons of SG-1 that tie back to Catherine’s story, and Continuum,” a source inside production told us. “The writers made a pact right from the beginning to pay close attention to canon and honor the rules and tone of the franchise — and keep listening to the fans. We broke down the details in all pertinent episodes and then referenced the canon threads to make sure we didn’t break continuity.”

Rather than breaking continuity, it might be the case that Stargate Origins adds material that prompts viewers of the entire, 24-year legacy to view certain events in a new light.

“Stargate Origins adds important new context to the life of the Stargate program’s true matriarch, Catherine Langford, revealing an original story written in a way that allows it to live in harmony with the Stargate timeline,” GateWorld’s source says. “And, most importantly, it adds new meaning to the existing Stargate canon.”

Of course this sort of broader context — you might say “retroactive continuity” — isn’t new to storytelling in the Stargate universe. The Stargate had never been opened before 1994 … until a good story came along in “The Torment of Tantalus” that revealed that it, in fact, had. Abydos was located in the distant Kaliem Galaxy … until it made more sense for the TV show to make it a close neighbor of Earth. And Achilles sailed into port without a hole blown in its side and a man from the future on board … until Continuum‘s time travel made it so.

In each case, Stargate’s continuity flexed and adapted to meet needs of a new story. When such retconning does occur, what is needed is a soft touch and a creative team that seeks to honor everything that has come before — and not blow it up.

Stargate Origins premieres February 15.