12 Responses

  1. daxmaryrussel
    daxmaryrussel
    (165 comments)
    August 23, 2011 at 1:43 pm |

    Yeah! Thanks – looking forward to this one

  2. SomeVeryRandomStuff
    SomeVeryRandomStuff
    (18 comments)
    August 23, 2011 at 4:11 pm |

    Your podcasts are excellent.

    The one thing i keep getting back to is that despite the fact that i wanted to love this show, and i religiously watched SGU on tv, and i even bought the DVD for season 1… SGU was a pile of steaming s***.

    Put it this way, if i wasnt a Stargate fan, i would have stopped watching after episode 6 “Water”.

  3. RichardJ
    (1 comments)
    August 23, 2011 at 7:06 pm |

    Hey, thanks for linking to my rewatch blog! (I’m number ‘Two’). I think I’m getting more into the swing of it now (just typed up /Singularity/).

  4. Gatefan1976
    Gatefan1976
    (21 comments)
    August 24, 2011 at 3:43 am |

    Well, an elightening podcast to say the least. It was interesting to note that the “main discussion” part of the podcast was more a huge “quibble” section more than anything else. It’s nice to hear some purely personal opinions on the podcast. (not because I happen to agree with alot of it, but it “feels” more “real”. At any rate, thanks Darren and David for the quick turn-around on this one, it is apreciated.

  5. Browncoat1984
    Browncoat1984
    (234 comments)
    August 24, 2011 at 7:17 am |

    I for one, enjoyed SGU. Yes, if it hadn’t had Stargate in the name I probably would not have watched it, but that’s why we’re Stargate fans. If Enterprise or Voyager had not been related to Star Trek, how many of us would have bothered with THAT show? And SGU was FAR more watchable than Voyager or Enterprise!

    And while yes, season 1 had some MAJOR MAJOR faults in pacing, I think they delivered on season 2 and if you don’t say that season 2 was a big improvement chances are you decided to check out after season 1 and not give it a chance.

    Of course, the damage had already been done by the end of season 1 and most people already HAD decided to check out, but everybody I know in real life who are Stargate fans who stuck through it, even if they didn’t like it at first because it was different by the end really liked it!

    Now Stargate is over, and not only is there no longer any Stargate on, this is the first year since Star Trek: The Next Generation aired that there has been absolutely NO space drama series on television, and that’s just plane sad. We need either A) George Lucas’ Star Wars series or B) a new Star Trek series to come along and revitalize interest in that aspec of the genre because while grounded series like Eureka and Fringe are awesome my first love is the space-based stuff because that’s what I grew up on.

    …does Doctor Who count as a space-based drama? I love that show…

  6. orfeu
    orfeu
    (41 comments)
    August 25, 2011 at 12:17 am |

    You lost me when declared Defying Gravity a great show. That show was a bad one, boring to tears.

    I was thinking at one time of proposing an alternative to the death penalty: watch SGU, Caprica and DG for eight hours a day, for the next five years, and if you don’t kill yourself in the mean time, you get your freedom.

    I just finished rewatching Firefly and I can not believe some people compare it to SGU. Firefly was brilliant, SGU just a bad joke.

    I really hope someday the people in power will return to making real SciFi, not soap operas in space.

  7. BluefanM
    BluefanM
    (1 comments)
    August 25, 2011 at 12:40 am |

    Due to work, I didn’t get to watch much of SGU when it was on Sci-Fi (or Syfy, whatever). I didn’t care for it, mostly since it was not anything like SG-A. However, due to some down time at home, I did buy the the S1 SGU DVDs, and found that I really, really like it. I have just received S2 and look forward to watching it this weekend. I click on the subtitles, that has greatly enhanced watching it. I am sorry that it didn’t last at least a 5-season run. Yes, some of the eps are not too exciting, but the dark side of the whole series is interesting, IMHO. I am sad that we Stargate fans have no more Stargate anything to look forward to. Perhaps TPTB at SyFy will eventually be booted out; could the new PTB listen to its audience and give better programming? (Get rid of wrestling and the stupid ghost stuff….Hello, SyFy!)

  8. kenna
    kenna
    (3 comments)
    August 25, 2011 at 11:02 am |

    I strongly believe this is the Stargate we’ve been waiting for. High drama, real tension and fantastic acting, especially by Robert Carlyle. I really can’t understand why people don’t like this show. It boggles my mind. I love the quirky antics of O’Neill, Jackson, Sheppard & McKay as much as the next person. But it’s been done, again and again. I think SGU is a refreshing take on the franchise. Why not give the sci fi element a little realism? Why not have aliens on a show that don’t speak english for a change? Why not break away from the SG-1/SGA mold and do something other than teams going on missions to visit other humans (in pacific northwestern-like forests) light years away for once? Seriously.

    This is a great concept for a show. I can barely wrap my head around the distance of “several billion light years” from Earth. It’s fantastic. The Destiny is a huge ship too. Who knows what they could have discovered had the show been supported and given the chance to live on. How are folks not digging this? I love all things Stargate. As bummed as I was to see SGA get canceled, this feels like the right step forward for the franchise now. The old formula is just old. And yet, that’s what people wanted. Unbelievable.

    Syfy cancelled the best show on television. SGU was the best thing to come out of the franchise. Period.

  9. DanMan
    DanMan
    (23 comments)
    August 27, 2011 at 3:56 am |

    I too loved SGU. I just watched the repeat of the finale on Sky HD and once again was captivated. Oh, and thanks for not censoring the final episode, Sky (“F**k the French” was still visible).

  10. Naomi
    Naomi
    (10 comments)
    August 27, 2011 at 12:52 pm |

    Thank you for posting a link to my Stargate re-watch blog (I’m the third one next to Fan Reviews). My thanks to folks who have taken a look at my blog. Comtraya!

  11. Deangrr
    Deangrr
    (3 comments)
    August 30, 2011 at 5:00 pm |

    Darren and David, just a comment about the Stargate Rewatch: I’ve really enjoyed your podcast reviews of the SGU episodes, and was wondering if you would do something similar for the SG-1 and SGA seasons (ie. review episodes or seasons after the fact and air listner comments)? I know you are doing the commentaries, but I’ve really enjoyed the post episode discussions.

    About SGU as a series:
    I really enjoyed parts of Season 1, the cgi and production standards being first class, but friends I invited to try the series found the pacing slow and switching bodies (stones) confusing. The camraderie, humour and action Stargate is famous for came back by season 2.5, but SGU had lived too long under the shadow of Battlestar Galactica and slow paced soap opera: it felt sometimes like a combo of BSG and Days of Our Lives.

  12. Skiznot
    Skiznot
    (34 comments)
    August 31, 2011 at 7:17 pm |

    Thanks for the podcast. Made me realize that I thought they rushed a lot of things in season 2 almost like they had a feeling that they wouldn’t get a season three and tried to wrap some things up. SGU had a brillian first 12 episodes then dipped and the Second half of season 2 got the mojo back.

    But over all for SGU, refer to Kenna’s post, it was the strong sci-fi that I have been waiting for from the Stargate Franchise.

Leave a Reply